Rather than assembling first, second, third and fourth team squads, the collegeinsider.com team consisting of 25 players. Division I coaches and NBA scouts are part of the selection process, but final decision rests with the collegeinsider.com staff.
| Cedrick Banks | G | 6-3 | (2001-05) | Illinois-Chicago |
| Jose Juan Barea | G | 6-0 | (2002-06) | Northeastern |
| Brett Blizzard | G | 6-3 | (2000-03) | UNC Wilmington |
| Taylor Coppenrath | F | 6-9 | (2001-05) | Vermont |
| Henry Domercant | G | 6-4 | (2000-03) | Eastern Illinois |
| George Evans | F | 6-7 | (2000-01) | George Mason |
| Luis Flores | G | 6-2 | (2001-04) | Manhattan |
| Nate Funk | G | 6-3 | (2002-07) | Creighton |
| Antonio Gates | F | 6-4 | (2000-03) | Kent State |
| A.J. Graves | G | 6-1 | (2004-08) | Butler |
| Caleb Green | F | 6-8 | (2003-07) | Oral Roberts |
| Kenny Hasbrouck | G | 6-3 | (2005-09) | Siena |
| Lester Hudson | G | 6-2 | (2007-09) | Tennessee-Martin |
| Trevor Huffman | G | 6-1 | (2000-02) | Kent State |
| Kyle Korver | G-F | 6-7 | (2000-03) | Creighton |
| Courtney Lee | G | 6-5 | (2004-08) | Western Kentucky |
| Alex Loughton | F-C | 6-9 | (2002-06) | Old Dominion |
| Kevin Martin | G-F | 6-7 | (2001-04) | Western Carolina |
| Eric Maynor | G | 6-3 | (2006-09) | VCU |
| Keith McLeod | G | 6-2 | (2000-02) | Bowling Green |
| Patrick Mills | G | 6-0 | (2007-09) | St. Mary's |
| Timmy Smith | G | 5-9 | (2002-06) | East Tennessee State |
| Rodney Stuckey | G | 6-5 | (2005-07) | Eastern Washington |
| Jason Thompson | F | 6-11 | (2004-08) | Rider |
| Jamar Wilson | G | 6-1 | (2002-07) | Albany |
| Ryan Wittman | F | 6-6 | (2006-09) | Cornell |
* years played in the decade are in (parenthesis).
NOTE: The team is actually comprised of 26 players, as there was a tie for the final spot on the roster
