Rather than assembling first, second, third and fourth team squads, the collegeinsider.com All-Decade team is one team consisting of 25 players. Division I coaches and NBA scouts are part of the selection process, but final decision rests with the collegeinsider.com staff.
| Carmelo Anthony | F | 6-8 | (2002-03) | Syracuse |
| Shane Battier | F | 6-8 | 2000-01) | Duke |
| Andrew Bogut | C | 7-0 | (2003-05) | Utah |
| Dee Brown | G | 6-0 | (2002-06) | Illinois |
| Stephen Curry | G | 6-3 | (2006-09) | Davidson |
| Juan Dixon | G | 6-3 | (2000-02) | Maryland |
| Kevin Durant | G-F | 6-9 | (2006-07) | Texas |
| T.J. Ford | G | 5-10 | (2001-03) | Texas |
| Jeff Green | F | 6-9 | (2004-07) | Georgetown |
| Blake Griffin | F | 6-10 | (2007-09) | Oklahoma |
| Tyler Hansbrough | F | 6-9 | (2005-09) | North Carolina |
| Devin Harris | G | 6-3 | (2001-04) | Wisconsin |
| Kirk Hinrich | G | 6-3 | (2000-03) | Kansas |
| Darren Collison | G | 6-0 | (2005-09) | UCLA |
| Sean May | F-C | 6-9 | (2003-09) | North Carolina |
| Adam Morrison | F | 6-8 | (2003-06) | Gonzaga |
| Jameer Nelson | G | 5-11 | (2000-04) | St. Joseph's |
| Joakim Noah | F-C | 6-11 | (2004-07) | Florida |
| Greg Oden | C | 7-0 | (2006-07) | Ohio State |
| Emeka Okafor | F-C | 6-10 | (2001-04) | Connecticut |
| Chris Paul | G | 6-0 | (2003-05) | Wake Forest |
| J.J. Redick | G | 6-4 | (2002-06) | Duke |
| Derrick Rose | G | 6-3 | (2007-08) | Memphis |
| Dwyane Wade | G | 6-4 | (2001-03) | Marquette |
| Jason Williams | G | 6-2 | (2000-02) | Duke |
* years played in the decade are in (parenthesis).
